
My recent
post and discussion with Tony Isaacs regarding the merits of oleander as a treatment for pancreatic cancer has started me thinking a bit about so called "alternative medicines." Perhaps I was a bit harsh if not mean. So, here it is short and sweet without the ad hominem. I don't believe there is such a thing as an "alternative" medicine or therapy. Treatments either work or they don't. If they work, then they're medicine. If they don't, then I guess they're an "alternative."
Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against flower extracts, bark tannins, seed oil, eye of newt, or any other purported remedy. I just want to know if it works or not. Give me a double blind study that shows a statistically significant difference between treatment and placebo and I'll tell you if it's medicine or not. Then show me several groups that repeat the treatment with similar results and I'll believe it.
But, I'll hedge my stance a bit. I don't even really have a problem with unproven treatments for common ailments. I'm talking about things like echinacea. I may not believe echinacea works, but I certainly don't believe anyone should stop using it if they believe it to work. Shoot, I even take "airborne" when I feel a sniffle coming on (even though I feel somewhat superstitious about it). There's no data to support the notion that vitamin C, zinc or anything else will boost your immune system to stave off the beginnings of a cold... but it's probably not going to hurt you. It's just not medicine.
I draw the line when these so called "alternatives" claim to treat terminal disease. At best, it's nothing more than a false hope. At worst, promoting an "alternative" directs patients away from proven treatments that will either lengthen lives or cure disease. This goes beyond silly and becomes dangerous.
Finally, when someone suggests that pharmaceutical companies are withholding "alternative" cures to continue selling half baked, sub-optimal remedies to needy patients... well, I'm offended. Lets' just say that I didn't embark on a lifelong career in science to get rich.
So that's it. Medicine either works or it's an "alternative." If you want to eat flowers to cure your ailments then go right ahead. Just don't lie about the efficacy of ingesting flower soup. If it works, then show me the data. As for me, you can keep the alternatives. I'll take the medicine.